Blog
When a Firewall Is Not Enough for OT: Physical and Protocol-Level Separation with Data Diodes
18 November 2026

In manufacturing, energy and infrastructure facilities, the OT network is usually separated from the corporate network with a firewall. That separation is logical and only as strong as the rule table; at critical boundaries we use OPSWAT MetaDefender NetWall data diode solutions to move separation to the physical and protocol level. This post explains the difference between the two approaches and how they fit together.
Separation with a firewall: necessary but logical
A firewall uses rules to decide which traffic passes between OT and IT networks. It is the foundation of segmentation and indispensable in most scenarios. But its protection rests on three assumptions: that rules are written correctly, that they are not loosened over time, and that the device itself is not compromised.
In the field all three are tested. A temporary rule opened for maintenance becomes permanent, permissions are widened for a new application, a vulnerability appears in the management interface. As long as a physically two-way connection exists, opening a path from outside to inside is always theoretically possible. That is exactly what is hard to accept for critical infrastructure.
Separation with a data diode: physical and protocol-level
A data diode is hardware that carries data in one direction only. The return channel is not closed in software; it physically does not exist. A rule error or a compromised external system therefore cannot establish a connection back into the critical network.
Physical separation
In a one-way hardware link there is no circuit to carry light or signal in the opposite direction. The OT network can send data, but no packet from the external network can reach it. This preserves the security level of an air-gap approach while letting the facility's data be used outside.
Protocol-level separation
NetWall products do not just provide a one-way link; they also apply a protocol break. No direct session is ever established between the two networks; the industrial protocol is terminated on one side, the data passes through the diode and is regenerated on the other. So an attack at protocol level cannot cross the boundary either.
The security of an air gap, the efficiency of a connected plant
A full air gap is the safest model on paper but unsustainable in practice: production data has to reach reporting, alarms the SOC, historian records analytics systems. That need is often met with USB sticks or “temporary” connections, and the air gap is breached in practice.
A data diode resolves that dilemma. SOC logs, production data, historian records and replication traffic are exported safely in one direction, while the isolation of the OT network stays intact. The organisation meets its visibility needs without leaving a door open into the critical network.
Which NetWall product for what?
| Product | Key feature | Typical use |
|---|---|---|
| Unidirectional Security Gateway (USG) | Hardware-based isolation and protocol break, Common Criteria EAL4+, 100 Mbps / 1 Gbps / 10 Gbps options, 1U rack | OT-to-IT data transfer in energy, water and manufacturing plants |
| Optical Diode | Hardware-enforced one-way optical link, 1U rack and DIN-rail models | Compact one-way separation in field panels and cabinets |
| Fend diodes | DIN-rail and wall-mount options | Small field sites and remote locations |
USG supports industrial protocols such as Modbus, OPC UA/DA/A&E, MQTT, IEC 104, DNP3, AVEVA PI and ICCP, and is positioned to protect historian, SCADA, DCS, HMI and PLC layers.
How do a firewall and a data diode work together?
A data diode does not replace the firewall; the two do different jobs at different layers. In the architecture we recommend:
- The firewall continues segmentation: traffic between cells and zones inside the OT network is managed with solutions such as MetaDefender Industrial Firewall, which inspects industrial protocols with deep packet inspection.
- The data diode protects the critical boundary: at the most sensitive boundary from OT to the corporate network or the cloud, traffic flows outward only.
- Files and media are handled separately: content entering the plant via USB or files is inspected separately with kiosk and file scanning solutions; the diode protects the network connection, not that entry point.
| Firewall | Data diode | |
|---|---|---|
| Type of separation | Logical, rule-based | Physical and protocol-level |
| Return path | Can open if a rule allows it | Physically absent |
| Impact of misconfiguration | Access may open | No return channel forms |
| Flexibility | Two-way, granular policy | One-way, predictable |
| Position | Zone and cell segmentation | The most critical boundary |
When should you consider a data diode?
- When OT data has to reach the SOC, SIEM or corporate reporting systems,
- In energy, water and transport facilities where regulation expects one-way or physical separation for critical infrastructure,
- In environments where the air-gap policy is breached in practice through USB and temporary connections,
- When backup or replication traffic needs to be carried one way into a secure zone.
The most important planning step is to define up front which data needs to flow in which direction. If a two-way need really exists (remote maintenance, for example), it should be handled with a separate secure access layer rather than breaking the one-way nature of the diode.
Rollout steps
- Data flow inventory: list the source, destination, protocol and frequency of every flow leaving the OT network, and flag flows that cannot be one-way.
- Choosing the boundary: select the critical boundary where the diode will sit, usually the transition between the OT DMZ and the corporate network.
- Preparing the application side: plan for historian, SIEM or reporting systems to read data from the source regenerated on the outer side of the diode.
- Parallel run and cutover: compare data flowing through the diode with the existing path for a while, then close the old two-way connection once consistency is confirmed.
- Simplifying firewall rules: once the diode is live, remove the old pass-through rules so the rule table shrinks too.
If you would like to assess together where a firewall and a data diode should sit in your OT network, contact our cybersecurity solutions team.